Psych Matters
Psych Matters is an informative and educational podcast by The Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists. Psych Matters provides regular interesting topics for psychiatrists, psychiatry trainees and others with an interest in psychiatry.
Disclaimer:
This podcast is provided to you for information purposes only and to provide a broad public understanding of various mental health topics. The podcast may represent the views of the author and not necessarily the views of The Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists ('RANZCP'). The podcast is not to be relied upon as medical advice, or as a substitute for medical advice, does not establish a doctor-patient relationship and should not be a substitute for individual clinical judgement. By accessing the RANZCP's podcasts you also agree to the full terms and conditions of the RANZCP's Website - RANZCP Website Terms of Use Agreement
Expert mental health information and finding a psychiatrist in Australian or New Zealand is available on the RANZCP’s Your Health In Mind Website - Your Health In Mind
Psych Matters
A Transformative Experience: Part 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this episode we continue with Professor Sidney Bloch's series of transformative experiences as he interviews Psychiatrist and Psychotherapist Jeremy Holmes to describe how a long-term therapeutic relationship with a patient named Jackie, alongside his engagement with John Bowlby’s attachment theory, reshaped his clinical perspective. Their conversation explores sensitive listening, co-regulating distress, therapeutic trust and boundaries, and how clinicians develop a distinctive professional voice.
Professor Sidney Bloch AM FASSA, Emeritus Professor of Psychiatry at the University of Melbourne is a Fellow of the Royal College of Psychiatrists, the Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists (RANZCP) and the Academy of Social Sciences of Australia (FASSA). He was awarded a Citation by the RANZCP for his academic contribution to psychiatry. He spent three years at Stanford University on a Harkness Fellowship and has been a visiting Professor in the Chinese University of Hong Kong, University of Hong Kong, Hebrew University, and Columbia University.
He has published 16 books, several of which have been brought out in new editions and/or translated. Russia’s Political Hospitals won the prestigious Guttmacher Award of the American Psychiatric Association, Understanding Troubled Minds the SANE award for the best book on mental health in 2012, and an award for An Anthology of Psychiatric Ethics from the British Medical Association.
Professor Jeremy Holmes MD FRCPsych is Honorary Professor at the University of Exeter and was for 35 years medical psychotherapist and Consultant Psychiatrist at UCLH and then in North Devon UK. He was Chair of the medical psychotherapy faculty of the Royal College of Psychiatrists 1998-2002. He set up the Exeter Psychoanalytic Studies programme in 1998. Author of over 250 papers and book chapters, his books include The Oxford Textbook of Psychotherapy (2008, co-eds Glen Gabbard & Judy Beck) John Bowlby and Attachment Theory (2014), Attachment in Therapeutic Practice (2017), and The Brain has a Mind of its Own (2020). His latest, The Spirit of Psychotherapy: a hidden dimension (Karnac) appeared in 2024. He is recipient of the Bowlby-Ainsworth foundation award, and the Canadian Clinical Psychology Goethe Prize. Gardening, Green politics and grand-parenting now parallel his lifelong fascination with psychoanalytic psychotherapy and attachment theory.
Topic suggestion:
If you have a topic suggestion or would like to participate in a future episode of Psych Matters, we’d love to hear from you.
Please contact us by email at: psychmatters.feedback@ranzcp.org
Disclaimer:
This podcast is provided to you for information purposes only and to provide a broad public understanding of various mental health topics. The podcast may represent the views of the author and not necessarily the views of The Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists ('RANZCP'). The podcast is not to be relied upon as medical advice, or as a substitute for medical advice, does not establish a doctor-patient relationship and should not be a substitute for individual clinical judgement. By accessing The RANZCP's podcasts you also agree to the full terms and conditions of the RANZCP's Website. Expert mental health information and finding a psychiatrist in Australia or New Zealand is available on the RANZCP’s Your Health In Mind Website.
We acknowledge Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as the First Nations and the traditional owners and custodians of the lands and waters known as Australia and Maori as Tangata Fenua in Aotearoa. We honour and respect the elders past and present who weave their wisdom into all realms of life.
SPEAKER_02Welcome to another Psych Matters podcast from the Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists. Psych Matters is a series of discussions on training and practice issues facing trainees and fellows of the college and other important topics in mental health.
SPEAKER_03Hello everybody. My name is Sydney Bloch, and I am a fellow of the college. I have been one for many, many years, and I'm actually speaking to you from the college today in the studio. And as you know, this is a podcast. And it has a particular theme or approach. And the idea is embodied in the phrase perspective which is transformative. We can also call it a transformative experience. But the key word is transformative. And essentially, before I introduce Jeremy Holmes, my colleague, with whom I'm going to converse about this, I just want to spend a word or two explaining what this is about. We all learn considerable amounts about ourselves and about the work we do and about other things that relate to our careers in a variety of ways. We could all name a number, clinical, ethical, philosophical, conceptual. I've got a whole long list here. But there may be an experience or some event or some moment, different terms can be used, which really stands out and which we can call transformative. And as the word indicates, it transforms something in ourselves which has a very important effect. And it may even and probably is enduring. So what we are doing in this series is that we're inviting colleagues from different parts of the world and different parts of psychiatry to share a story that did have a transformative effect on them. So let me now introduce Jeremy. Jeremy is an old friend and colleague whom I much admire, and he was very, very appropriate as a choice for this particular series. Let me just introduce him in the sense that he went to medical school in England, in Cambridge University. He went on to do his psychiatric training in London, University College of London, and then became a consultant psychiatrist and psychotherapist outside of London, which is a little unusual, in North Devon, where he worked for many years until he retired. He's had visiting professorial appointments, University College London is one of them. And he is an eminent writer and lecturer, and I've always enjoyed reading his works and hearing him lecture. So have I got that right, Jeremy? Not far wrong. Not far wrong. If you'd like to add something, then you welcome.
SPEAKER_04I've had many very enjoyable visits to Australia and to the college, so just to add that.
SPEAKER_03Well, I also just want to add that uh the writing that Jeremy is very well known for revolves around more than one theme. But I suppose the hero of the story is John Bowlby and his theory of attachment. And we will have Jeremy talking about that because we have discussed how we want to focus on uh different topics in this podcast. I don't want to spend too much time on myself, because that's a little invidious, but um I trained uh in another country, University of Cape Town, eventually via Australia landed up in Britain. I then went to the US, a bit of a wanderer, and landed up in Oxford, where I probably saw more of Jeremy than anybody else, and eventually uh got back here and became um member of the University of Melbourne Academic Department, and I'm now an emeritus professor there. So, Jeremy, what um I'd like to ask you to do as a starter is to tell us the circumstances that you've chosen which makes for this transformative experience. Right.
SPEAKER_04Okay, well, thanks, Siddharth. As always, it's always very nice to have a discussion, conversation with you. Always very enjoyable. I just wanted, before I we get on to my own transformative experience, just say a little bit about the concept, which I think is a really interesting one. It relates for me to something that I'm currently sort of involved with and preoccupied with, which is climate change. And there's a lot of talk in the climate change uh literature and discussion about tipping points. So we need uh it seems to me a transformative experience is a kind of tipping point. Now, what do was what does one mean by tipping point? Um one way of thinking about it is you're sitting on a chair, you're leaning backwards, and then just one small little change then changes everything. And uh uh we all have this in our vocabulary. Uh it used to be called a damascene moment, didn't it? Paul. So I think this idea of uh a tipping point is really important. Um it's important because after all, we are trying to help our uh patients, our clients, I'm never sure which word to use, change. Change in a more uh towards a more healthy kind of uh direction. And so in a way, we need to be um have our antennae out for tipping points in our clients' lives as well. So that's just a something I wanted to say about that. And if you think about tipping points, I think they're not so strange because in a way, if you think about the developmental process, that also always includes tipping points. And this obvious example is when a child learns to walk or talk. So there's this wonderful moment when suddenly a child takes their first steps. That is a transformative moment, or says their first word. But of course, what one needs to think about is everything that's gone before, because it takes that child a year of kicking and pushing and half standing and um so on before they take their first step. And so a tipping point, as it were, has a build-up, and then of course it has a f uh a sort of follow-up because the moment you can stand up and walk, you're now in a new sort of universe, as it were, and the same is of course is true even more strongly when it comes to language. Um so you suddenly go from babbling to saying your first word, whatever it might mean, mama or something, and then now you're in the world of language, which is transformative. Another slightly general point I want to make is all of us, as it were, uh have developed as mental health professionals. So we've been through a kind of developmental experience, and we've been uh to medical school, or we've been um to uh clinical psychology school, etc. And we've learned our skills, we passed our exams, but the developmental process hasn't finished. Um and I'm very interested in post-qualification uh development. What happens to you once you trained and you're a member of the College of Psychrists or you're working as a clinical psychologist? What's the developmental process that follows from that? And in a way, what I want to talk about in my case is that process or that moment where I feel I move from being a qualified psychiatrist or qualified psychotherapist, but still not really, I would say, myself, and not really having found my own voice. And um, what I'm going to talk about is two things in a way that come together. And these two things, on the one hand, are an experience with a specific patient, um, and I'm able to talk about this patient without too much worry about confidentiality, because as it happens, this patient, Jackie and I, wrote together, um, well, we didn't write it together, but we published in the British Medical Journal, they had a series on patients and their doctors, and uh it covered physical illnesses as well as psychological illnesses, and we were invited, or I I can't remember quite how it happened, but anyway, we I think we were in or I was invited to contribute to this, and Jackie and I together wrote something about our uh clinical relationship. So I'm not going to be breaking confidentiality by talking about Jackie because it's all in the public domain. So what I want to talk about is a kind of transformative experience which came on the one hand from my working with this particular patient who, as it happens, I think I worked with for at least twenty years. On the one hand, a patient with major depressive disorder, and on the other hand, if you like, theoretical relationship with or finding a theory that really sat easily with me, namely attachment theory and working with John Bowlby's, and together they produced a kind of transformation in the way I approach my work, which I think continues to this day. I'm still working very minimally in my hotel.
SPEAKER_03You mentioned the developmental and you started with the child and the one-year-old, and then in your own case you start with when I graduated as something, psychiatrist, whatever it is, and after that something happened in a transformative fashion.
SPEAKER_04There's a moment, you know, babies taking their first step. That is a moment, that's a transformative moment. But actually, that that's the end result of all kinds of um practice um and developing muscles and developing um uh balance systems, etc. So um there's been a huge amount of work going on in the nervous system of that child that results in that first step. And I think uh the same is true of this these psychological transformative moments, if you like. Um so it although there is a a kind of turning point, that turning point is a is the resultant of work or processes that have been going on for many years.
SPEAKER_03I'm curious that you discovered that through Jackie, this particular patient, certain things were different in the way you looked at psychiatry at your clinical role, maybe other things. So in the years prior to that, you'd been training as a medical student and then as a psychiatric trainee, were there a preparatory or anticipatory issues or experiences that got you to Jackie and the tipping point. Now you mentioned that in the terms of the baby. I'm just wondering also in the context of yourself, were there several things that went along or were you conscious of things that went along?
SPEAKER_04Well, yes, is the short answer. I'll um go to sort of describe the these two parallel processes, because you remember I'm trying to suggest in this conversation that there's a kind of theoretical transformation and there's a clinical, if you like, or pragmatic, or in the consulting room, the way I actually uh interact with my clients and my patients transformation. And they came together, uh at least in the story as I'm telling it. So if we start with this sort of theoretical side, I've was always drawn to the psychotherapeutic part of psychiatry. I think I've been a reasonably efficient psychiatrist, I'm able to prescribe appropriately for patients with major mental illness. But my real interest has been in psychotherapy, in the use of, as Michael Barlin, one of my teachers, used to say, the doctor is the drug. The question is what dose and how frequently it should be prescribed. So I've been interested essentially in the therapeutic relationship and how this can be used to produce change, including transformation, in our clients. That was my main sort of interest. And when I was training, uh, the main uh psychotherapeutic modality that was available was psychoanalysis. And although I became a member of the psychoanalytic psychotherapy organization, the guild of psychotherapists, psychoanalysis never fully satisfied me. There were a number of sort of issues and difficulties in the psychoanalysis. I saw it as a bit of a cult. I felt that the evidence base for psychoanalytic work was somewhat questionable. I've always been more of a kind of common factors psychotherapist. In other words, I've I've felt that the similarities between different psychotherapeutic approaches are probably more important than the differences. So, although I was drawn in a psychoanalytic direction, I never never felt really comfortable with psychoanalysis.
SPEAKER_03Yes. What what you just said seems to me that there were preparatory steps. That may not be the right word, or you were primed to uh change in certain ways and to undergo this transformative.
SPEAKER_04If I stay with my walking analogy, there's a kind of randomness about transformative moments. Uh in other words, I always quote, I've just written a memoir actually, and the title of my memoir is a quote from Kierkegaard, living forwards, understanding backwards. Um, in other words, when you're having a transformative moment, you don't know that you're having a transformative moment. They they just kind of happen. And it's only when you look back and you say, ah, that was a transformative moment. The same thing applies to these first steps I've been talking about with a child. I mean, you don't know on which occasion that child is suddenly going to start walking or talking. It just kind of happens. So that said, I I can say a bit about how I've inverted colours and attachment theory, found a home, was transformed from being um someone who, you know, I did my job, I I knew how to be a psychiatrist, I knew how to be a psychotherapist, um, I knew how to make interpretations, but I wasn't fully identified with that uh uh uh process. In our developmental process, in a way, uh this is goes back to Piaget, we start by a kind of imitative process where we kind of so in my case as a psychotherapist, I probably sort of said the kinds of things that my supervisors I imagined would have said, um, or I said the kinds of things that my own analyst would have said to me, to my patients, but I hadn't found my own voice. And what I'm talking about is finding your voice. Well, this is the transformation that I I chosen to talk about. And in the case of attachment theory, it's also finding a kind of home, as it were, from which you can find your own voice.
SPEAKER_03I just uh want to compare, not regularly, but in my own case I also went through this theoretical phase, and it was mainly psycholytic, there were other aspects to it. But then I recognized by reading actually, rather than through a patient or patience, that there were other ways of looking at things, and so I was very attracted to the existentialist type worker and writer, famous man of Yalom in Stanford, and I read him with great avidity, and uh fortunately I got the opportunity to work with him for almost three years, and that in a way was my home from then on. So I think we're talking about something similar. Are we? I think so.
SPEAKER_04I think we are, yes.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. So maybe with that preamble, important, of course, we should turn to the story that you have shared in the BMJ and are going to share, fortunately, for us now. And um as you say, confidentiality is not an issue, fortunately. Can you then tell us about Jackie Hobson as this patient who helped you to see things in a new way?
SPEAKER_04What happened with Jackie was she came to see me, she had a history of major depressive disorder, she was pregnant, and she was worried, I think probably I'm not sure whether good or not so good cause, that because of her major depressive disorder she might not be considered uh suitable to be able to bring up her child, and she wanted the psychiatric support and the psychotherapeutic support that would enable her to carry out her role as a mother. She was an extremely intelligent, well-educated woman, and so we settled into weekly psychotherapy. I also had a role as a psychiatrist with her as well, so I managed I was combining my psychiatric and my psychotherapy role. So I just prescribed antidepressants. From time to time she needed admission to hospitals so I could admit her into my ward. That was happening not often, two or three times, over the course of twenty years. And um when she became really low and depressed and suicidal. In my psychotherapeutic work with her, I was I was playing it by the book. I think this is the point that I'm trying to make. This is the transformative aspect. I was playing it by the book, and so if you like, the psychoanalytic book says depression is related to anger. And so um I would I can't exactly remember the kinds of interpretations that I made, but they were along the lines that a lot of her depression was a kind of unexpressed anger, quite a difficult developmental background. Um her parents were Holocaust survivors, actually, and I think they were shopkeepers, they were very preoccupied with just keeping going, staying alive, staying keeping their financial heads above water, and were probably not able to interact in a very sensitive way. And so I banged on with my um interpretations about anger and depression. Um and then um it so happened that in parallel with this, I was writing a book about John Beloughby and attachment theory, and I was hugely drawn to attachment theory because, unlike conventional, if you like, or mainstream psychoanalysis, attachment theory emphasized, first of all, the importance of evidence, so it fulfilled the criteria of scientific evidence-based practices. Secondly, there was a lot of emphasis and is still a lot of emphasis in attachment theory on real trauma and how this shapes a person's psychological states. Whereas conventional psychoanalysis at that time, that's in the late 80s, 90s, was still quite ambivalent about trauma. There was m more emphasis on the way in which a person was responsible for their own trauma rather than trauma as a sort of external illness-producing phenomenon. So attachment theory fulfilled the criteria, what I call Cambridge science, secondly, the emphasis on trauma, and thirdly, and probably most importantly, it was essentially a relational science. It's about relationships. Attachment theory is about attachment, it's about what goes on between caregiver and child, what goes on between spouses, what goes on between therapists and their patients, perhaps. So those three criteria sort of struck a chord in the. And as listeners are probably familiar, a firm distinction is made between secure attachment and insecure attachment and the different varieties of insecure attachment. What's going on in psychotherapy is that the client comes in states of insecure attachment, and while our job as therapists is to help that client towards a more secure attachment relationships, towards what was later called earned attachment. I feel that's applied to me. I think I moved, with the help of my analyst and my wife, from a rather avoidant attachment stance to a more secure one. So I then, from the literature, try to understand what goes on in that first year of life that is the difference between a child who aged one or one and a half is classified in a strange situation as secure or insecurely attached. And a key term that came from Mary Ainsworth, who was John Bilby's equal collaborator in developing attachment theory, was the concept of sensitivity. So caregivers, usually mothers of babies in that first year of life, they're sensitive. They respond rapidly and appropriately to their children's distress. And they also, as we now think of it, they weren't think of it in those days, they are able to mentalise their child. That's to say, they see their child as separate from themselves, having experiences of their own, and they're able to relate to that in a sensitive and appropriate way. Let's come back to Jackie now. I realize that I wasn't offering her a sensitive response, in the sense that I wasn't actually mirroring her experience. And I began to start to try in our therapeutic relationship to mirror, underline, I can explain those two words, they have a sort of technical meaning as well, her experiences of incredible distress at having been admitted against her will to hospital when she was a student. The incredible distress, the pain of major depressive disorder, mental pain. I don't think I'd really, I was so quick to make interpretations and turn that depression into anger or something that I hadn't actually mirrored the pain. I had a GP colleague, a very distinguished GP, who, as well as being distinguished, suffered both from depression and he had artery thrombosis, he had a heart attack. He said the pain of depression is far worse than cardiac pain. So I started to move in the direction of Of validation of Jackie's pain, Jackie's distress, Jackie's worries. And at the same time, um I went back to something that she'd said to me, which sort of stuck in my mind. I told you she was highly educated, she'd done an English degree, and she suddenly quoted one day from King Lear at me. She suddenly said, take physic pomp. I think what take physic pomp meant was, you psychiatrists, you therapists, you're projecting all your own distress into your patients. And you need to look at yourselves, you need to look at the ways in which you are, as it were, not experiencing your own pain, you're projecting your pain into your patients, and as it were, treating your own pain at a distance. And so that, again, if we think about the way in which my therapeutic stance has changed, I'm moved, I'm all the time trying to be sensitive to the patient's actual in the room, here and now, present moment experience, and particularly that is stress. I'm trying to respond, as it were, rapidly or appropriately, and I'm thinking about um to the extent to which own difficulties are sort of being projected into my patients. I try to put myself more firmly out of the room and simply be there for the patient. The final point I want to make is this developmental process has actually continued, and I now see uh um what happens between therapist and patient in terms of what I call the borrowed brain.
SPEAKER_01I hope that you're enjoying this podcast. If you have a topic suggestion or would like to participate in a future episode of Psych Matters, we'd love to hear from you. Please contact us by email at psychmatters.feedback at ranzcp.org.
SPEAKER_04So I moved in the direction of saying that Jackie was sort of borrowing my brain in the sense that we were now together experiencing whatever distress it was that was bothering her at that particular moment. And the idea being that if you can recruit another person to co-regulate your distress, then that distress becomes tolerable and manageable, and you can work with it in whatever appropriate way seems possible. And that, indeed, it seems to me, is what goes on in secure attachment. And I sometimes give the example moving away from Jackie for a moment, going back to babies and walking and talking, but the baby wakes in the night, six-month-year-old, let's say, the mother goes to that baby, or it could be the father or the grandmother, whoever the caregiver is, goes to that baby, and that caregiver puts their own feelings to one side. I mean, the mother may be thinking, oh my god, I've got to get up at six in the morning to go to work, but she doesn't think about that. She goes to her baby, and then she sort of enters that baby's world. Are you too hot? Are you too cold? Um, do you need your nappy changed? Are you do you need a feed? Have you had a bad dream? So that baby borrows the mother's brain, or the mother's brain and the baby's brain enter a similar space with a similar boundary around it, and that enables that baby's distress to be co-regulated. So the mother, even though the baby's not verbal, has a conversation about what that baby's distress might be. The mother tries various things, puts the baby to the breast, or just um changes their napy, whatever it happens to be. So I feel that is the sort of process that goes on in the consulting room now. I put myself to one side and I try to enter the mental universe of my client in this co-regulatory way. And that is how I've found my voice, and therefore it was a tipping point, with the help of attachment theory, because I realized the significance and importance of this responsive sensitivity, which we now call mentalizing, and I realized that I was pushing my own theoretical ideas about depression and anger onto the client rather than validating that client's distress as a first step in the direction of helping them towards transformation.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, well, what I am curious about is the following. She writes her own story, and it's quite a moving and tragic and bitter and and in some ways horrendous story. Now you have focused on your theoretical substrate and on something that was happening in you personally, but I want to throw up of the question of other things that were going on in her life, preceding, coming to you, and while she was with you. For example, from my own experience of working with patients, Holocaust parents usually have a tremendous influence. And I just wondered to what extent that played a part in what you were doing. Another thing, for example, is that uh there were certain favorable life events she talks about and what uh that meant to you and what you dealt with those sort of stories. They were, I thought, quite different to the chronic depressive outlook she had. And also she talks about her treatments over the years, and some were dreadful, county asylum, ECT, and all the rest of it. And you said yourself that you had to be a fully fledged professional, in other words, you had to also think about medications as well. So filling in the story with all these other components seems to be a tall order. I know you saw her for many years, but she was going through a hell of a lot of things, and I just wonder how you encapsulated them within your theoretical framework, within your transformative experience.
SPEAKER_04If we talk about this particular person, add up to transformation, a patient is always in a context, and again, I think attachment theory has alerted me to that. If you have a sort of very, very pure psychoanalytic approach, you may be less tuned in to the context in which the client lives, their marriage, their role as a parent, and their friendship, their occupation, etc. I mean, I may be unfair there, but in Jackie's case, there are a number of hugely important things. First of all, she became a very successful mother. Her daughter's flourished, it's done very well. That was an antidote, as it were, to her depression and low self-esteem. Um, a really interesting aspect which you touched on just there, was that she came, you might say, with a kind of somewhat avoidant attachment stance, at least vis-a-vis her background, her childhood. She had, I think she was the first member of her family to go to university. She kind of distanced herself from her parents, and from her particularly from their trauma that they'd been through. I think they themselves had also distanced themselves, so there was no discussion really of the Holocaust in the family. In the course of therapy, I'm not saying I don't take any credit for this myself, she began to be interested in this, and she began to learn, she's very clever, as I said, she began to learn Hebrew. So she was kind of she'd moved, as it were, from this avoidant stance in which you maintain a degree of integrity, a degree of uh being able to cope with life, but at a price, because you're cutting yourself off from history, you're cutting yourself off from all kinds of feelings. And then uh the the third point I want to make there is is that her husband to whom she was devoted, right? So uh this was a terrific trauma for her, but she was able to grieve his death. And I think again, rather than avoiding the pain, avoiding the grief, which I think she had in order to survive, she'd done before, she was actually able to experience her grief and her sadness and her loss. And out of that, after a little while, she met her present husband, who is utterly devoted to her, and I think she to him, and it's a very good marriage. And they have a huge amount in common. And that husband is quite important uh in my work with Jackie because going back to this idea that this relationship between sensitivity and a secure attachment, I mean it's a very simple thing. Mothers of uh securely attached infants, when that infant uh is distressed, they respond quite rapidly. They pick them up, they soothe them, they don't hang about. So the husband, although I didn't have I didn't do any couple work or anything like that, but if Jackie was not well, he would ring me and I would try to fit her in immediately or as soon as possible, or on one or two occasions actually admitted her to hospital. Now it's the wrong word to use, but she embarked on a PhD. And it was a very interesting PhD because it was a PhD that was relevant to her. What she was interested in was the portrayal of mental illness in the media. She directed her rage, rather than she directed her rage at me, you know, take physic pomp, at the media, the way in which the media portray mental illness. I can can't uh um give you all the examples, but one of them is at Halloween. Children, I believe, dress up as schizos, in other words, people suffering from schizophrenia. Um so she, a PhD, um, she read all the literature on the ways novels which contain people suffering from mental illness. I never promised your Rose Garden is one example. Dibbs is one that several I certainly read when I was training to be a psychotherapist. So she, as it were, put her own illness, if you like, to good use. Um again, that gave her a sense of mastery, a sense of creativity, and it was transformative.
SPEAKER_03Look, what I'm getting to here is that she underwent a transformative experience or life. Lots of things happened to her. You've uh shared quite a few examples, and this was during the course of your seeing her. So I'm just trying to figure out this parallel transformative, let's call it experience again. Were you very sensitive to matters like her parents or her PhD? What sort of impact did these things have?
SPEAKER_04I'm glad you said that, because it enables me to say one more thing that I haven't touched on particularly. But going back to um what I said right at the beginning, that I've always been an advocate, if that's the right word, of common factors in psychotherapy. I mean, that goes right back to Lester Leborsky back in the 1970s, who wrote this famous paper, the Dodo Bird verdict, which relates to Alice in Wonderland and the statement by the dodo after a race that all have won and all shall have prizes. In other words, what Leborsky said was, well, actually, when you look at it, the outcomes from the different modalities of psychotherapy, whether it be psychoanalytic or couple therapy or CBT, are not that different and the similarities are much greater than the differences. And then what are these common factors? Well, one of the common factors, I won't go into that, it's a different discussion, is what I call, and what is I think called in the literature, engagement. Now I think engagement is particularly important for people who've got a psychoanalytic background like me, because as a psychoanalyst, it's quite easy not to be engaged with your clients. You can adopt a very, very passive, silent posture and make what are often very brilliant and clever interpretations, but they somehow may not hit the spot with a client very easily. I suppose from a psychoanalytical perspective, you'd be saying, well, you know, you you go on making these interpretations year upon year, and then one day they suddenly do hit the spot. I'm sure there's some truth in that. But I've become very interested in this idea of engagement. Now what uh it's hard to actually define exactly what engagement means, but it I think it means that you sort of do enter into the client's life world. In this transformative phase, I moved towards really becoming engaged with Jackie, engaged with her role as a parent, engage with her academic prize, engage with her marital developments, engage with her bereavement when her husband died. But in the moment of the therapy, in the fifteen minutes with the client, you and your client there's a sort of sense in which there's a kind of merging, and you are a sort of an extension of the client. Going back to this idea of affect co-regulation that the mother does with the child. Similarly, the therapist is there to co-regulate the client's distress, their depression, their sadness, their anger, their anxiety, and use their uh thinking capacity to help modulate the client's feelings.
SPEAKER_03But I surmise that some colleagues who are listening to this, and I think there's a touch of this in myself, that one can be, you said immersed and engaged, but could you also be submerged by so many events that occur in her life where it's awfully difficult to remain as you were, fully engaged. Was that going to be a problem as you transformed your perspective?
SPEAKER_04This is where the the idea of boundaries are so important. Yes, that's right. In the last year or two I've become a patient myself, not not not a psychiatric patient, but for a physical illness. I used to say to my trainees of my patients, it's only our job it's their life. And you need to keep remembering that so that when you keep a patient waiting in an outpatient clinic or something of that sort, as a professional, you know, you're not that bothered. But actually, if you've got some serious illness and you have to wait an hour to see your doctor, that hour can be completely suffused with anxiety, etc. Now why am I saying this? It's to do with boundaries. So, you know, in a way we doctors, we psychiatrists, we psychotherapists, we're pretty horrible. I mean, we offer ourselves to our clients for fifty minutes or however long it happens to be. And then we say it's time to stop. And if we get an email from them, you know, saying, 'I need to see you this week,' we might have a tendency to say, Well, I'm sorry I can't fit you in us, you know, we have to wait till next week. So I think built into the therapeutic relationship is a kind of structure which means that you don't become over involved in your client's life, and it's very important not to be. And I think actually, although I've been sort of in a way mildly critical of the psychoanalytic approach, I think we could adopt an edible view of this and say part of the child's developmental experience is to go through the eatable phase. Or what is the edible phase? Well, the edible phase is to discover when you're two, three, four, that you're not the only pebble on the beach, and that your mum doesn't really belong to you, and that mum and dad need to go to the bedroom and close the bedroom door, uh, maybe make another baby who's going to be a sibling and an arrival. So, in a sense, the boundaries of uh our work as psychiatrists or psychotherapists help that client, though they may protest about this and uh one has to work with this. Uh I think I don't know whether you've had this experience, but I've certainly had the experience of clients sort of saying, Oh, you don't give a damn. You just you're just doing your job. And I see that sort of in edible terms. So the client simultaneously is sharing their experience with their therapist, but they're also, in a way, realizing that it's their life, and in the end, it's for them to make their own choices and to cope with separation and loss as well as sensitivity in relationship.
SPEAKER_03Now we are coming up the home stretch. So a couple of things I would like to raise. You've used the phrase supportive therapy, and I've used that as well over the years. It's usually somebody who really needs to be supported and where the collaborative effort is difficult to accomplish. And you also raised the question in your own comments after Jackie's comments, about trust. And I just wondered to what degree those points are relevant in the broader context that you've been describing.
SPEAKER_04Yes, in a way it's another discussion. But I think I'd just pick up on the last point first, the trust aspect. I think what what was good about uh my relationship with Jackie was that although at times I think she was very angry with me or hated me or felt that I was nowhere near understanding her, at some level she trusted me. Because she stuck it out, she didn't leave, and she must have felt that she could get frustrated and angry with me, and I would stick around, and I wouldn't palliate. So trust is absolutely central, I think, to our work. But it'd be very interesting to think about what what does it mean to trust someone, and uh specifically in the clinical context. Partly, of course, you know, the patient trusts you because society has bestowed upon you your medical degree, your psychiatric qualification, etc. Um so there's that sort of external trust. But I think there's also a sense in which the client needs to feel you're trustworthy. And again, this may be external in the sense that you're you're there for the appointment. You don't cancel appointments, you don't turn up late, you don't turn up drunk, you are more or less consistent, you wear the same sort of clothes, you the way you behave in the session is predictable. All these things are tr uh components of trust. But there's a kind of a deeper trust aspect, and that I think probably has to do with the capacity to listen. It's a funny business being a psychiatrist and a psychotherapist because you're you know, I think Freud called it the talking therapy, but it's really the listening therapy. So the the fact that you open a space inside yourself where the client feels they can, at least for the fifty minutes they're with you, be accommodated. I sometimes talk about what I call triple listening. You listen to what the client says, you listen to the way in which you're responding to the client, so you're listening to yourself, and then you listen to how the client responds to anything that you say. So listening isn't just literally listening with your ears, it's also listening to yourself and the way you're behaving, and you're listening to the relationship. So trust, yes, absolutely sort of central to the whole process.
SPEAKER_03I might just uh interject there by saying that I always taught students to listen with the third ear, and you've mentioned tripartite, and also the adjective active, and it'll be an active listener rather than a passive recipient. So the final thing, what ultimately endures to this day? Is it the bulbe? Is it the trust? Is it the engagement? Or is it too difficult to distinguish between them? Because I think some of our colleagues in training, particularly, would want to know how do I go about this? What do I do first? What's the most important? So I'm throwing out a a rather complex question at the very end.
SPEAKER_04I think there's a paradox in going back to this idea of common factors. Again, I'm going to use an analogy with language. We know that it's throughout the world, actually, multi or polylingualism is the norm. And we Brits um outliers in that we tend really only to be able to speak our own language, English. Whereas uh around the world most people speak more than one language. I mean, we're talking earlier about you uh at least have a very working knowledge of Hebrew, etc. Of course, we all learn French or German or Italian at school, now Chinese and Japanese. But you need a mother tongue. So my feeling is we therapists um and we psychiatrists, we need to find our mother tongue. And in my case it was attachment, but it could easily be CBT or couple therapy or systemic therapy or melee therapy. You need to find your own language. But having found your own language, this is the paradox, you then need to be open to other languages and other therapeutic approaches. So although I'm fundamentally psychoanalytic, um uh I'm also very interested in couple therapy, family therapy. We live forwards, understand backwards. So I don't really know how I stumbled upon attachment theory. I just did, and it seemed to work for me, and then the more I got involved in attachment theory, that became transformative of myself. Similarly, a a child takes their first steps when they're at their granny's house or something, but then they can walk the world. So there's a stumbling aspect to a child's first steps, and there's a stumping aspect to our certainly it was in my case, to finding attachment theory. So I think uh if I was giving advice to trainees, I'd say just follow your instincts, go in directions that seem to make sense to you, and then allow the transformation to take place and see what happens. There's always a balance in the attachment model between security and exploration. Though you need to feel safe. We've got our psychiatric training, we've got our fundamental, in my case, psychoanalytic training, we need to feel safe, we've got a kind of bedrock there, but we need to explore. And it was that exploration that led me in the direction of attachment theory. And it was that explor in relation to Jackie that enabled me to move from a rather distillant interpretation-giving person to someone who was more sensitive to her actual experience.
SPEAKER_03When I was taught by Sir Dennis Hill, a very distinguished English psychiatrist, I said, How do you learn this you had retired, what was your main source of learning? People, I don't know if I have a main source of learning, but the thing that really struck me was that I used to stumble. Very same word, maybe you were taught by him as well. And I thought, hey, wait a minute, you can stumble upon something good. Wow, look what I've found, or look at the person I met, or you can stumble and fall and fracture a limb. So is it for you personally that this stumble and this direction you took occurred is for you, and you're not going to necessarily indicate to others, I think you've said that, each person really has to walk along this pathway of development, and so different things may happen.
SPEAKER_04Yes, we're staying with your analogy. I mean, after all, we psychiatrists and psychotherapists are dealing, I'd almost say primarily, with loss, mental pain, and recovery. Some people call this rupture and repair, trying to help our clients to repair the ruptures in their lives, the developmental ruptures that they've had, the traumata that they've had. So I think, yes, exploration and stumbling may entail a degree of fracture and rupture. Things can go wrong, and we need to be able to tolerate that and realize that we can always recover from a fracture. I mean, that's the great thing you learn in medical school that you break your leg, but actually the body has these incredible reparative processes. And I think the same is true in our work as psychiatrists, although I feel that in the case of psychiatry, the reparative phenomenon is the relationship. In other words, it's very, very hard to recover from a psychological rupture without help. And if we think about Shiva, for example, going back to bereavement social processes, Shiva, as I understand it, is all about drawing on your community to help you recover from your loss. And I feel that what we're doing as psychiatrists and psychotherapists is providing a relationship which can help you recover from your loss.
SPEAKER_03Thank you so much, Jeremy. Uh, from the bottom of my heart, very sincerely, for sharing all this with you. It's not easy to share a patient's story unless you're in a formal academic type setting and it's in confidence. And neither is it that easy to share yourself. And obviously, this series is about sharing oneself, and you've done that admirably. We're all very, very thankful for that. And we will add some key references uh as well. So thank you so much, and uh hopefully we will meet again, maybe in even these circumstances of podcasting.
SPEAKER_02We hope you enjoyed this episode of Psych Matters. Feel free to share it with others and keep an eye out for future episodes. Psych Matters is produced by the Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists.